The men responsible for the Wilcox Train Robbery escaped, police were dispatched from all directions, and a wild chase on horseback ensued. Rumors flew about who the robbers might be and how much money they made off with. “The shipments of money west are said to have been unusually heavy lately, and from this fact estimates as high as $30,000 have been made to-day,” read a Sacramento Daily Union report at the time. “Those who place the amount high do so largely from the fact that a tremendous effort is being made to catch the six men.” Despite several shootouts, the police were unsuccessful in capturing the robbers.

The gang made off with roughly $50,000, which is equivalent to $7 million in modern-day currency, as noted by The Telegraph. The Sacramento Daily Union reported that their haul included $10,000 worth of diamonds, and that the gang destroyed a substantial amount of their loot with their own dynamite.

There were three theories about the robbers’ identities at the time. One was that the heist was carried out by railroad workers who were working on train grades nearby. Another was that the gang was led by a man named Jack Nolan. And the third was that the men were involved with Butch Cassidy’s notorious “Hole in the Wall Gang.” The third theory, of course, was true. (Cassidy is pictured above.) And, per The Telegraph, dollar bills with charred corners turned up everywhere from New Mexico to New York in the years that followed.