What It Was Like Serving On The Scott Peterson Jury
On December 24, 2002, Laci Denise Peterson, who was eight months pregnant, was reported missing by her husband Scott. In an interview with police, Scott Peterson said he last spoke with his wife at their Modesto, California, home on the morning she disappeared. He then went fishing. When he returned home later that evening, Laci had seemingly vanished without a trace.
As reported by Biography, authorities became suspicious of Scott Peterson based on his demeanor and his refusal to cooperate. In addition to refusing to take a polygraph test, Scott seemed to be unusually calm about the disappearance of his wife and unborn child. The authorities’ focus on Scott only intensified when they learned he was having an affair with another woman.
In April 2003, the bodies of a woman and a fetus were found on the shore of San Francisco Bay. Four days later, they were identified as Laci Peterson and her son — whom she planned to name Conner. Biography reports Scott Peterson was arrested and charged with murder later that same day.
Scott Peterson was ultimately convicted of first-degree murder in the death of Laci Peterson and second-degree murder of Conner. He was initially sentenced to death. However, as reported by Biography, his sentence was commuted to life in prison by the California Supreme Court in August 2020.
The trail of Scott Peterson was emotionally draining for everyone involved, including the families of Scott and Laci. However, it was also took a toll on the jurors.
Three jurors were dismissed during Scott Peterson's trial and deliberations
During Scott Peterson’s trial, and the subsequent deliberations, Judge Alfred Delucchi dismissed a total of three jurors. The first dismissed was Justin Falconer. Although Judge Delucchi did not explain why he was dismissed, CNN reports Falconer was seen talking to Laci Peterson’s brother, Brent Rocha, while they were passing through court security. Falconer said he told Rocha, “I’m ruining the shot for the news tonight. You’re not going to be on the news tonight.”
Falconer said he was jokingly referring to the fact that the media could not use video footage or photos with jurors included. However, some members of the media, who overheard the remark, said Falconer actually said, “You’re going to lose tonight.”
As reported by CNN, Juror number seven, who was later identified as Fran Gorman, was dismissed during deliberations for “conducting independent research” about the case. Per the court rules, jurors are prohibited from conducting their own research into a case and are instructed to base their decision solely on information presented during the trial.
Judge Alfred Delucchi also dismissed the jury foreman, who was later identified as Gregory Jackson, during the deliberations. Although Delucchi did not explain why he dismissed Jackson, CNN analysts said he likely “violated the judge’s instructions.”
Following the dismissals of Fran Gorman and Gregory Jackson, the jury was required to restart deliberations. However, Judge Delucchi refused to declare a mistrial.
Gregory Jackson's dismissal may have changed the jury's verdict
Prior to Judge Alfred Delucchi’s dismissal of Gregory Jackson, the jury was reportedly unable to agree on a verdict, and the case was headed for a mistrial. As reported by ABC News, Jackson, who is an attorney and a former medical doctor, was the only juror siding with the defense when he was dismissed.
After the conclusion of the trial, John Guinasso, who was juror number eight, said Gregory Jackson sided with the defense based on the testimony of Dr. Charles March.
The prosecution alleged Scott Peterson killed Laci on December 24, and her death ultimately caused the death of their unborn child. They also alleged Scott disposed of Laci’s corpse on the day of her disappearance and death. However, Dr. Charles March testified that Conner did not die on the same day as his mother.
As reported by ABC News, legal analysts suggested March “fumbled badly on the stand and did not come across as credible.” However, Gregory Jackson thought his testimony was credible and raised reasonable doubt.
John Guinasso said Jackson “became flustered” when the other jurors dismissed his opinion. At one point, Jackson reportedly said, “I want off the trial. I’ve never been at a meeting like this in my life and there’s too much hostility in the room.”
ABC reports Guinasso said, “My personal opinion is … if [Jackson] was to remain on the case I think we would have had a hung jury.”
A juror who remained on the case is now being accused of lying
One of the jurors who remained on the Scott Peterson case until its conclusion has since being accused of lying during jury selection. As reported by The Modesto Bee, Richelle Nice, who was juror number seven, was asked whether she was ever the victim of a crime during the jury selection process.
When questioned, Richelle said she was never the victim of a crime. However, it was later revealed that she sought and obtained a restraining order against her then-boyfriend’s ex-girlfriend in the years prior to Scott Peterson’s trial. According to Richelle’s complaint, the woman was threatening and stalking her. At the time, Richelle was four months pregnant.
It was also revealed that Richelle Nice was the victim of domestic violence, which was perpetrated by another ex-boyfriend while she was pregnant with another child.
As reported by The Modesto Bee, Scott Peterson’s attorneys said Richelle Nice intentionally lied during jury selection “in order to serve on Peterson’s jury and punish him.” The attorneys said Richelle’s own experiences with threats to her unborn children would have excluded her from the jury. However, as she did not disclose the incidents, she was wrongfully allowed “to sit in judgment of Mr. Peterson for the crime of harming his unborn child.”
As reported by KRON4, Richelle Nice’s attorneys said the claims against their client “are false and without merit,” and Scott Peterson’s attorneys are simply “grasping at straws.”
Five jurors discuss their impressions during the trial
Jury selection in the Scott Peterson trial took a total of three months. As reported by Dr. Phil, the original jury was equally divided between men and women, and the jurors were predominantly white. In the months following the conclusion of the trial, five of the former jurors, who were identified only as John, Julie, Mike, Richelle, and Greg, discussed their time on the jury and their perceptions of the defendant and the evidence presented.
Jurors Julie and Mike both said they had favorable or neutral impressions of Scott on the first day of the trial. During the interview with Dr. Phil, Julie said he “did not look like a monster” and was “a handsome man.” Mike said he noted Scott was around the same age as his son, and clearly “had just suffered the loss of his wife and child.
Juror John said Scott looked like “the typical all-American boy,” but he acknowledged the defendant’s “eyes were eerie.” Juror Richelle said she was struck by Scott Peterson’s upbeat demeanor, as he was on trial for murdering his wife and unborn child.
In the interview with Dr. Phil, Juror Greg said he “never saw emotion out of Scott.” However, he “looked at him as actually being a victim of the process.” Greg admitted his impression of Scott changed throughout the trial. In his opinion, the testimony presented by Scott Peterson’s mistress, Amber Frey, proved that he was “a habitual liar.”
Jurors were frustrated when the death sentence was commuted to life in prison
Although the jury sentenced Scott Peterson to death by lethal injection, his sentence was commuted to life in prison in August 2020.
As reported by ABC News, Peterson and his attorneys appealed his conviction and original sentence citing an unfair trial. In addition to “the unusual amount of pretrial publicity surrounding the case,” Peterson’s attorneys argued that a number of prospective jurors were “erroneously dismissed” when they admitted they were opposed to capital punishment.
The California Supreme Court ultimately rejected Scott Peterson’s claim that his trial was unfair, and upheld his conviction for the murders of his wife and son. However, as reported by ABC News, the court did overturn Scott Peterson’s death sentence, as they determined “the trial court made a series of clear and significant errors in jury selection that, under long-standing United States Supreme Court precedent, undermined Peterson’s right to an impartial jury at the penalty phase,” (per ABC News).
In an interview with KTVU2, jurors Mike Belmessieri and John Guinasso expressed frustration with the California Supreme Court’s decision. Guinasso said he is “frustrated” that he and his fellow jurors made the unanimous decision to sentence Scott Peterson to death, “and it hasn’t been followed through yet.” Belmessieri said he blames the system. In his opinion, the legal system needs to become “a little more efficient than what it is.”
Neither Mike Belmessieri nor John Guinasso regrets their decision to convict Scott Peterson of murder or sentence him to death.
51 thoughts on “What It Was Like Serving On The Scott Peterson Jury”
Leave a Reply
This May Be How Butch Cassidy Got His Nickname
The Tragic Real-Life Story Of Princess Diana
States With The Most Endangered Species
The Great Commission In The Bible Explained
This Is How Murderer Ned Kelly Was Finally Caught
Inside The U.S. Swim Team Controversy At The 2016 Olympics
Here's How Much Land In England The Royal Family Actually Owns
The Difference Between State And Ceremonial Royal Funerals
Why The Smiths Decided To Call It Quits
How Bob Ross' Military Career Led To His Calm TV Persona
fenofibrate 160mg cost tricor for sale order fenofibrate 200mg pill
cialis 10mg pill cialis 10mg without prescription brand viagra
generic zaditor 1mg buy doxepin 75mg without prescription brand tofranil 75mg
minoxytop buy online buy generic minoxytop cheap erectile dysfunction pills online
cheap precose 25mg buy glyburide online order griseofulvin without prescription
buy generic aspirin 75mg imiquimod over the counter buy generic imiquad
order dipyridamole 25mg generic plendil ca pill pravastatin 10mg
meloset tablet cerazette 0.075 mg ca danocrine 100 mg tablet
buy duphaston online januvia price order empagliflozin without prescription
generic florinef dulcolax price order loperamide
prasugrel 10mg uk tolterodine drug buy tolterodine 1mg online
pill ferrous 100 mg order betapace for sale betapace cost
mestinon 60 mg pills buy piroxicam 20 mg online buy generic maxalt over the counter
buy generic enalapril over the counter oral duphalac buy lactulose
buy generic zovirax online capecitabine over the counter buy rivastigmine 6mg for sale
buy prilosec 10mg sale singulair 5mg brand order lopressor 50mg generic
purchase telmisartan online cheap hydroxychloroquine 200mg usa buy generic molnupiravir 200 mg
cialis tadalafil 40mg tadalafil 5mg price viagra tablets
buy pepcid 20mg for sale buy tacrolimus generic prograf uk
azelastine nasal spray acyclovir 800mg brand avapro 150mg sale
order esomeprazole 40mg capsules oral mirtazapine 30mg buy generic topiramate
order generic zyloprim allopurinol 300mg for sale crestor 20mg sale
sumatriptan 50mg over the counter avodart 0.5mg cost order dutasteride for sale
order buspar 5mg online order amiodarone for sale buy cheap generic amiodarone
order zantac 300mg pill ranitidine 150mg us celebrex 200mg for sale
purchase domperidone generic buy cheap domperidone tetracycline 250mg price
buy spironolactone 100mg valtrex for sale order proscar generic
help me write a thesis help writing papers buy thesis paper
buy diflucan tablets baycip pill baycip canada
aurogra 100mg canada sildenafil 100mg drug buy generic estradiol over the counter
order metronidazole 200mg online how to get trimethoprim without a prescription keflex order online
lamotrigine pills buy vermox 100mg generic order mebendazole online
order cleocin without prescription buy sildenafil for sale order fildena 50mg generic
tretinoin generic order avanafil 200mg online cheap buy generic avanafil 200mg
tamoxifen us nolvadex buy online where to buy budesonide without a prescription
order generic tadacip diclofenac 100mg cost indomethacin 75mg cheap
purchase ceftin pill careprost us methocarbamol order online
desyrel 50mg sale buy clindac a online clindac a uk
order terbinafine pill online canadian casino real money online slot games
aspirin 75mg tablet online card games casino games online real money
affordable term papers trig homework assignment cefixime brand
help me write a research paper free slot games for fun gambling casino online
amoxicillin canada cheap trimox buy macrobid without prescription
clonidine 0.1mg canada meclizine 25 mg uk buy generic spiriva 9 mcg
maximum strength acne medication progesterone only pill for acne buy trileptal generic
minocycline where to buy order minocin 50mg pills requip 2mg drug
order uroxatral online drugs that reduce stomach acid acid reducing medications
new pill to quit smoking arthritis old medication names buy prescription painkillers online
buy medroxyprogesterone generic buy hydrochlorothiazide medication buy hydrochlorothiazide without prescription
antivirals drugs list inhaler price without insurance glp 1 agonist drugs list
purchase cyproheptadine online cheap buy periactin pills ketoconazole 200mg drug